Wally's on Broadway, the proud home of the #BUFFALOPIZZABEAST, is making waves in Buffalo's pizza scene. Located on Broadway, this pizza haven promises an unforgettable culinary experience driven by fresh ingredients and innovative flavors. Customer reviews consistently rave about the mouthwatering pizza, with many praising the perfectly thick crust that is bursting with flavor. A standout feature is the unforgettable cheese blend; it melts seamlessly and pairs beautifully with a variety of toppings. Yassmine Mccarter highlights the satisfaction derived from her pizza experience, remarking on the stellar boneless wings and delightful cannoli that rounded off her meal perfectly. The deep dish option is another must-try, particularly loved for its unique sweet sauce and spicy undertones. Laura Lee's partner’s deep dish made an impression with its crispy crust and generous toppings. The attention to detail doesn’t stop there, as diners appreciate the friendly atmosphere and excellent service. Moreover, the out-of-this-world sweet potato fries and the Pittsburgh salad showcase Wally's versatility beyond just pizza. Customers cherish every bite, often returning for more. With glowing testimonials and rave reviews, Wally's on Broadway is destined to become your new go-to spot for an exceptional pizza experience in Buffalo. Don’t forget to try the #BUFFALOPIZZABEAST and savor what makes this place unique!
Amenities and More
Accessibility
Does not have assistive hearing loop
No wheelchair-accessible car park
No wheelchair-accessible entrance
No wheelchair-accessible seating
No wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Offers kerbside pickup
Has no-contact delivery
Offers delivery
Offers takeaway
Popular for
Popular for dinner
Good for solo dining
Offerings
Serves comfort food
Serves late-night food
Quick bite
Serves vegetarian dishes
Dining options
Serves dinner
Serves dessert
Atmosphere
Casual
Crowd
Good for groups
Planning
Doesn't accept reservations
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Accepts debit cards
Credit cards
Children
Good for kids
Parking
Free of charge street parking
Free parking lot
Photos
Reviews For Wally's on Broadway (home of the #BUFFALOPIZZABEAST)
Yassmine Mccarter
Apr 30,2025
I ordered the pictured items and let me say I am very satisfied with my order. I've never been here before until today and cant wait to try the rest of the menu. I'll start with the pizza- I love love love the crust, it was filled with soo much flavor and the thickness was perfect. The cheese melted in my mouth and the blends of the toppings made it so much better. The boneless wings were very tender and not too hot and lastly the cannoli hit the spot. It was just enough chocolate chips and the filling was fulfilling. I will highly recommend.
Robert Pitchure
Mar 30,2025
My favorite pizza place. Updated with the last pizza I got(steak!) So much cheese and topping I could feel the difference in weight when I picked it up. 2 slices ended up filling me up so I'll probably get like 4 meals out of this loaded up pizza
Laura Lee
Mar 30,2025
My partner got the deep dish w/ sweet sauce and pepperoni. I'm gluten free, while they do a gf crust i opted for their Pittsburgh salad. It had the best fries ! Next time I'm getting a side of fries. The salad was terrific. Fresh and crisp the dressing was awesome. My partner is in love with the pizza. The crust was perfect. The sauce is sweet yet has a great spiciness! You can really taste the oregano. The wings were meaty and perfectly cooked. Everyone I spoke with was super friendly and helpful. This is our new go to pizza place! Now we just need a Bills game.
LuckyZ's Hero
Mar 7,2025
I have eaten alot of pizza But by far perfect amount cheese to sauce .love the crust .sweet potato fries were by far the best I have ever experienced. Consider you added to my fav list . I ordered through takeout taxi . Highly recommend,don't believe me see the photos .
A K
Feb 24,2025
I am not going to lie but I figured Wally's was gonna be one of those regular ol pizza shops where it always is traditional, but not there! I got myself a quarter sheet pizza (6 slices) and the look, quality and taste was superb! I give it an A for effort all around, I definitely would highly recommend for those looking to get a delicious pizza . Dough was the right thickness, sauce had exceptional flavor, with the cheese melted to perfection, and got the sweet drizzle on top and absolute 5 star rating
Savanah Smiles
Feb 20,2025
Love me some wallys. Food is always fresh and good. Large portions flavorful and worth the money. I got stuffed shells n sausage, fried dough with extra butter and garlic bread. Everything was so good. Give it a try!
Jim P
Feb 16,2025
Fish fry Friday! They came Pizza boxes, fantastic! Lots of great tasty food for a fair price! Will see them again! Edit: here again, keep coming back year after year, five star fish fry! I really have no idea why there isn't a line out the door for these fish Fry's!!
Fenner “Aquafina” McKinnis
Feb 4,2025
My first time trying Wally’s and they didn’t disappoint!!! We ordered a sheet pizza and 50 wings(half Chivetta’s & half honey mustard), along with a deep dish cheese & pepperoni pizza. If you’re looking for a deep dish...(My husband says no need to go to Chicago, go to WALLY’s) our 2 teenage boys also give 2 thumbs up!!! Everything was delicious I love finding hidden gems #NewCustomers4Life!!!!
Reviews For Wally's on Broadway (home of the #BUFFALOPIZZABEAST)